THE MEEK HAVE SPOKEN BUT WHO IS LISTENING?

When the Lord said the meek shall inherit the Earth, to my mind that was the biggest election promise of all times. Because the fact is that no one ever listens to the meek.

I have always wondered why leaders in democracies never learn from drubbings they or their opponents get every now and then.

Maybe because voting in a democratic election is very much like shopping in a flea market. There are second hand goods on display, tried and tested and also discarded from time to time. In our flea markets, a lot of them are even stolen goods. The salesmen are adequately tired looking, flogging their wares with a sense of déjà vu. The customers are the only jokers in the pack. They know what they are getting into once they enter the market area and yet are driven towards it, again and again, hoping to land a miracle and net gold at the price of  lead.
             From time to time, a new kid emerges on the block, a better salesman, feverish excitement in his voice, magnetic eyes; he puts up a more energetic act managing to convince his customers that he is actually the only one selling Rembrandts at the price of peanuts. The crowds flock, sales increase and the rest of the flea market looks on in envy.
              And then there follow the inevitable withdrawal symptoms. The colors tend to fade, the promised Rembrandt looks pedestrian and the new kid on the block joins the ranks of the other salesmen. What does not change is the customer, always on the lookout for yet another sighting, another new deal, another awakening. And so the story goes on and on…

That is us the humble voter; voting again and again in the fond hope that this time will be different. It is the same for the American voter.

The media is overflowing with reasons why Trump and his party failed big time. With no alternate vision of society available, elections these days are lost, not won. What we are not hearing anyone even whisper is what happens next when the new Congress and Senate take over.

It is the Trump factor. He has lost but not lost power. And no one can stick his neck out to say what happens next.

So here goes…

By his own admission the issues that drove the minorities, women, the youth and the rest away from Trump were majorly, the Iran fiasco, affordability, immigration controls, rising costs of diesel, Medicare and no course correction in sight.

The most obvious way for the Democrats would be to pass legislation that would mitigate these factors in a big way and see how the President or the Republicans stymie it at greater political cost.

But what is obvious rarely happens in public life because there are always wheels within wheels in behind the scene maneuvering.

At a rough count out of 100 senators at least 73 are millionaires with Democratic caucus holding an average worth of 2.9 million against 5.7 million for Republican senators. And that is the catch in democracies the world over. The masses looking for a better deal in life have to choose between millionaires to decide their fate. Only the scale of riches held by elected representatives vary from country to country.

Obviously such worthies who have made their millions from the present arrangement have a stake in status quo. Any disruption in the economic field will leave them hurting. Thus the empty sloganeering.

The US economy has bet big on AI. Big tech is pushing it with all its might. The revenue stream from AI is still not more than a trickle. But it has generated even more debt and data centres are the latest villains on the block because of water and electricity guzzling. 

But there seems little hope of the AI push reducing whatever the atmospherics because all the millionaires are betting on it. There is always the China factor to justify its continuance. See the momentum being built up to get the Ex Nvidia boss back. Too many big guys have their stakes in that business and are convinced he has no replacement.

Be that as it may, going after misdemeanors in the administration is a must for the Democrats. As long as they go after the gang Trump may make appropriate noises but will throw them under the bus. That is his past record.

But if the Democrats go after the Family it will be war. He is primarily a real estate businessman. He knows all about cutting losses and making deals. He is making the right noises of willingness to work with Democrats. He is also sending mixed signals by appointing Miller as his Chief of Staff.

If the Democrats do take the plunge, it will be something the Republicans will love because it will derail all other conversations at Capitol Hill. Then it will become a street fight, the Republicans will get a cause to unite and the administration will manage to stonewall such efforts.

Corruption in public life is a given. There are too many instances of such acts from both sides of the aisle to recount. It will make much more sense to introduce legislation to eradicate the underlying causes of corruption like lobbying for example and then make a song and dance about it when it is stuck.

But that will mean disturbing status quo. I doubt if the Democrats will be up to it. There is another fly in the ointment for Democrats. The status quoists in the party will run up against the Democrat Socialists and it will be interesting to see how that pans out. Because if it all hangs out in the public domain, the Democrats will look a house divided.

And above all, the masses and the Democrats will have achieved nothing. The Republicans will be back in business in the next elections and the voter will be back to square one punishing Democrats.

Round and round the mulberry bush we go…..

Standard

DISRUPTION IS THE FLAVOR OF THE SEASON

Trump getting kicked in the backside is a continuum of the mayhem in Europe. It has clearly emerged as a fight between the top moneybags of society and the bottom of society’s pyramid. The bottom has had enough and they are hitting the streets.

It is a world wide trend. 57 countries are affected b6 civil unrest as per International group crisis watch.

The story in democracies the world over is indicating the same script. Govts are holding high debts, capital is in short supply and economies are growing but the gains are not diffusing to the bottom. It is jobless growth the world over because higher productivity today means more automation.

As money is in short supply with the govt, education and health are easy targets. The protests started with that trigger in Europe till housing and living conditions took over.

We have reached here thanks to the left liberal govts that held sway for decades. They wore their bleeding hearts on the sleeve but got cozier with big business all the time. Big business teamed up with technology to take the human out of the production cycle. Jobs shrank and by the time the govts woke up, the genie was out of the bottle.

How else does one explain the Biden message as he was being shown the door by his party? Or maybe he spoke the truth because he was being shown the door.

The Right used the immigration bogey for a while to counter the Left liberal open door policy. But the educated voter has seen through the bogey and results are for all to see. Even in Europe, the Right is making gains but no breakthroughs yet.

The sad part is as Trump showed; the Right is even more pro moneybags than the Left.  One of the main reasons for the upheaval in Texas, a Red state, was the mess the education system was left in.

So the masses have had no choice but to go back to the Left. The sadder part is that even the Left in the US is full of millionaires. It will be interesting to see where the water level settles in the Democratic Party in the battle between the status quo guys and the progressives.

The Indian establishment is understandably also in a funk because sadly business models are the same the world over. But as usual we are in a better space, the hysteria being whipped up by the establishment notwithstanding. But then they have to cry wolf to show their indispensability.

The reasons are twofold.

And we have to thank Kejriwal for the first one. Introduction of the revadi culture was decried by all and sundry. But as time has proved, the logic was overwhelming.

Since independence, two areas that suffered consistent neglect and continue to do so, are primary health and education. We have perpetually been short of money. So  today we have an army of youth who are ill prepared to join the diminishing productivity cycle thanks to the State not having done its duty.

What the revadi culture has ensured is that it has acted as a pressure release valve. The free rations to 80 crore people is part of the same approach. It also gives us an idea of the journey we have to travel before we become a middle income country or Viksit Bharat.

In 2006 we launched MGNREGA. It guaranteed 100 days of unskilled manual labor for every rural adult. It was our first admission that 60 years of independence had let down a vast number. In 2020 because of Covid we launched the free ration scheme for 80 crore people. Subsequent extensions came in January and November 2023 for 5 years. The slip is showing big time.

The in kind social transfers ranging from food grains to laptops, cycles and school uniforms have pushed nearly 22 crore people comprising around 19%of rural population and 8.4% of those in urban areas into higher consumption brackets, an NSO study shows; once the monetary value of free goods is imputed. 

It also reduced consumption inequality, pointing to a boost in effective purchase power as it freed up cash. It acted as a progressive measure as maximum upward mobility was concentrated at the bottom of the pyramid. It is a conservative estimate as Ayushman Bharat, free schools, mid day meals etc were not added in the survey.

The second equally valid reason is that we Hindus are a house divided. Attempts at homogenizing Hindus is making the BJP go through hoops like beef being normal in the North East and fish in Bengal during Navratras and no meat up in the North during the same period. A vibrant caste system that continues to flourish adds to the mix.

We cannot act as a monolith and thus are easy prey to conversion. It is a historical fact and continues to be one.

But thanks to the appeasement of the conservative elements of the minorities by the Congress, the Indian middle class lives in a feeling of minority like insecurity. And sadly doing little to actually help.It needs the BJP to give that feeling of security that the party provides in ample measure. As a result all its failings are condoned.

And the Opposition does its bit by not being able to take a stand either way. So there does appear little reason  to think that there will be protests of the 1975 type.

There is a catch however. GDP is growing but jobs are not at a commensurate rate. There are 87 million Indians between the age of 15 to 29, who are not in education, employment or Training currently (NEET). Only 8.25% college graduates get a job commensurate with qualifications as per Niti Ayog.

In October, our economy did not add any jobs in the service sector. Companies reported that their existing workforce had sufficient capacity to manage current workloads despite pick up in business activity.

The economic fallout on consumption that drives our GDP big time, if such conditions continue, need not be spelt out.

So while we have time before push comes to shove, the writing on the wall is not much different, albeit in much smaller letters. We need to make a strong departure from current practices if we hope to break out of the present state.

Reform or perish as the cliché goes. Maybe that is why the Chief Economic Advisor to the govt refers the current situation to a 1991 like scenario. He may be right in more ways than one.

Standard

TURBULENCE IN A DEMOCRACY

The oldest democracy in the world is facing turbulence to put it mildly. The next two months will flesh out the infinite possibilities that dominate the air waves in the US today. Just tells us how artificial this form of governance is; given our caveman instincts.

As a 75 year old democracy and by miles the largest; we are facing turbulence too. But we are a third world country whose democratic credentials have denied definition. And we have already been there done that a few times. The important part is whatever the hyperbole we are still there.

In 75 years there were two phases when we were rocked by large scale protests. One was in 1974/75 and the second was the anti corruption movement in 2011.

In 1974, it was a student movement that overthrew a democratically elected govt in Gujarat. It was under a Navnirman Yuvak Samiti. Several young activists who participated in the movement later became major players in Indian politics. Among them are Narendra Modi and Amit Shah.

What was good for the goose then is now not so good for the gander. That is the circle of life.

The other mass movement that was earth shaking for our democracy was in 2011. It was initiated by Baba Ramdev and followed up by the Anna Hazare movement. It had the backing of all opposition parties including the BJP. They capitalized heavily on public anger against UPA to build momentum against the then govt.

The 70s movement was striking in that it came close on the heels of the decisive Indian victory in the 71 war. Both movements were driven by an underlying economic factor of inflation, lack of job opportunities and perceived corruption in govt circles.

The foreign hand was an important factor played upon by the govt in its defense during the 70s movement given the Bangladesh creation in 1971. Amazing how history repeats….

To be fair, the current govt had nearly all the bases covered. The press was largely compliant, the opposition was handsomely divided and there was enough good happening in the economy to be able to spin a feel good factor for the chattering classes.

But sadly the soft underbelly that we possess will not go away by such factors. And if 60% of the country’s population is on free ration, it is a truth that cannot be wished away however hard we may chatter.

The sad fact is that economic mismanagement by Congress led to MNREGA. This govt has modified MNREGA and added free rations for 80 crore.

The single biggest mistake th govt made for the economy was cutting corporate tax a la Trump, in 2019; in the fond hope of spurring private investment. And lost revenue of more than a lakh crores per year in the bargain.

It is only when GST rates were cut, 6 years later, that consumption increased and some green shoots of increase in investment are now visible.

But that is history. Where do we go from here?

The cockroach remark by the CJI will go down as the first breach in the dam of public dissent. There may be opinions about how the agitation at Jantar Mantar 1.0 was handled but that is in hindsight.

As the govt is realizing, there is no rulebook on how to handle democratic dissent. Once the leaks in the dam increase, it is a case of, damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

It is a sign of the changing times that Rahul Gandhi is getting more rounded critiques than earlier. The huge turnout in the opposition march to the SC does not augur well for the govt.

Every action that the govt takes now will have an equal and opposite reaction. It has not been great politics to defend the CEC so whole heartedly. Now it is committed.

That there has been overreach by the EC is evident by a simple fact. It takes literally labor pains to get enrolled as a voter today or prove you are one. But it takes a simple mail or letter to disqualify any number of voters, now reduced to 10. Is it logical?

The best the govt can do in the present scenario to my mind is to let the SC bring down the anomalies of the EC working, without the AG mounting stirring defenses for its actions. That is the only approach that will take the wind out of the sails of the opposition movement.

It will also help the CJI recover some of his lost sheen after his off the cuff remarks have not exactly put him in great light.

It is an action that will go against the DNA of this govt but then it has only itself to blame for pushing itself into a corner by rooting for the EC. Let us hope better sense prevails and the county can go back to preparing for the major external headwinds it faces.

.

Standard

OUR ONLY HOPE IS AI

The biggest peaceniks are soldiers. That is simply because they know the cost of war. Ironically, guys who have not even seen the border are generally the loudest in wanting the country to go to war.

A similar scenario is playing out in the field of AI today. The guys who are working at the frontier edge of this technology are the ones who are pleading to apply the brakes. And the ones who do not seem to understand the perils that lie ahead are saying bash on.

There is a big dilemma here. AI development needs to be controlled or do we allow AI to be developed full speed ahead. Because it is clear that the one who controls AI, controls the world.

The other possibility emerging is that machines could control the world if AI develops unchecked. The signs are already there.

Take a step back. Human intelligence with all the aids developed to assist it so far, has led the world to a bit of a mess today, mildly stated.

 We have wars going on for years that we cannot stop. Oligarchs are ruling the roost all over the world. They control technology and all resources; natural and developed. Govts of all shapes and sizes are mere putty in their hands.

Govts may come and go, faces may change but the oligarchs continue to remain in the driver’s seat. They are too big to fail, that is the dominant phrase in all major economies.

All major economies are under high stress the world over. They are under high debt; jobs are already in short supply and they are running a welfare state beyond their means to keep anger off the streets.

Of course, we have excuses for why we are failing. We have immigration and religion the two big excuses that dominate political discourse the world over today. Our leaders promise us that once these two bugs are sorted, all will be well.

And since we have little choice, we believe them.

And because oligarchs are too big to fail and cannot be controlled, nothing in the world can be controlled today. Wars, climate change, epidemics continue unabated and innocent lives are lost as we hurtle down a one way street.

We have big tech, big pharma, big military industrial complexes, big manufacturing and we in India have a big market. And as they have grown bigger these biggies have transcended national boundaries. So we have global interdependence but we have leaders who do not know how to handle it.

So we see them in a flurry of meetings all over the globe. Xi condescends to come to India but misses dinner then recovers to meet Trump who suffers him in Washington, Putin shuttles all over, Zelenskyy is never in Ukraine, EU leaders rush about, Carney is in a frenzy of trips; but there are no breakthroughs.

The world needs each other but does not know how to meet halfway. Our leaders at the helm just do not possess the intelligence to pull it off. That sadly is the bottom line.

Remember Mandela and de Klerk? It was personally a complex relationship between a jailor and the jailed. Yet with all the mutual distrust they moved forward to end apartheid and bloodshed and SA had the first multi racial elections in 1994. That is leadership.

 Today we have pygmies. But we have installed them. That says something about us.

And the guys working on AI seem to know it.

Big tech today has already worked out algorithms to nudge us into particular directions based on our preferences. Improvement in data availability will ensure that these algorithms will improve further in accuracy. So heads or tails we are destined to become bigger prisoners of big tech in the days to come.

Actually what are these guys who seem so well meaning trying to do? In a way they are ensuring that they stay in control and the machines do not run away from their control. Either way we masses are going to be controlled more viciously in the future. Which control will be better? It is like asking what is better, being in a frying pan or the fire.

As early as Sept 2025, Albania brought in Diella, a minister of State for AI. She is an AI assistant. Her core responsibility is to oversee public procurement and state purchases. It is an admission that humans are too corrupt to be able to handle these matters.

Is this the way forward? Give AI a high seat at the decision making table and make its decisions final and binding on all disputes, internal and external?

Because the decade of the 20s of this century has clearly shown that we humans have landed ourselves in such a mess that we do not have the intelligence to clear it. We need a higher order intelligence to help us.

Mere mortals like you and me are already turning to AI to solve our emotional, medical and financial problems. It only remains for our leaders to face the stark truth. They need leadership of AI.

This decade has made it abundantly clear that they cannot do it by themselves.

Do they have that limited intelligence at least to be able to come to that conclusion? Because I suspect this brand of leadership knows not that it knows not. And we have voted them in. Amen.

Standard

BLIND MEN AND OUR ELEPHANT GDP

First things first. Our democracy is alive and kicking even if SIR has just reduced our voting population by 13 crores.

This is how it works. The noise starts on social media. It reaches a crescendo. Then the mainstream media reluctantly takes it up. Debates and shouting matches follow. Then the govt issues a rebuttal.

Sometimes the govt rebuttal appears on mainstream media before the protesting reason is spelt out clearly. All is well.

Ditto for the GDP figures just released. But the good thing in this case is, conclusions can be contested, some figures from this time period cannot.

  • Car sales were up 25.6 %.
  • Tractor sales were up 19%.
  • Cement production was up by 8.8%.
  • Industrial production was up 6.2 %
  • Steel output 4.8%
  • Exports up 16%
  • Net FDI up 7.8 billion dollars as compared to 4.7 billion

There is more. In a long time industrial, service sector loans over took personal loans as bank credit surged. Fresh capital expenditure surged to a 5 quarter high even as govt capital expenditure declined 36%.

But of course it is not all great news. It seems there are two parallel stories running in the Indian economy and they do not seem to be converging.

A stated goal of the govt was to increase the share of manufacturing in the GDP to 25%. Fresh investment in this sector fell 40%, from 3.8 lakh crore to 2.2 lakh crore in this period.

Its contribution to the GDP is presently 13 to 14%, down from an earlier 17%.

Investment in food products industry, textiles, chemicals and construction materials also declined.

Construction sector saw a decline in investment from 40,900 crore to 15,000 crore.

All these sectors are major employment drivers.

Projects worth 1 lakh crore were abandoned or shelved in the quarter.

Data centre investments catered for the 4 time jump in IT sector investment. Electricity was the other major investment area. Possibly also data centre driven.

Exports increased but decreased in employment generating sectors like gems, jewellery, textiles, leather etc. in this period.

Youth unemployment continues at 16%, urban youth at 18%. And it is not too difficult to figure out why. Growth areas are all non labor intensive.

And Niti Ayog just gave a figure of 8 crore plus youth who are not in Training, Education Employment(NEET).

Private consumption that contributes 55% of GDP has increased from 6.8% to 7.1% but gold loans for meeting personal expenditure are going through the roof, increasing by 70% for NBFCs and 105% for banks.

As of March 2026, outstanding gold loans stand at 18.5 lakh crores.

RBI has flagged a dramatic surge in household debt. The debt to GDP ratio is currently at 45.5%. The grim part is that nearly 60% of it is household borrowing for consumption and not tied to housing, agriculture or business.

Surjit Bhalla, who was a clear supporter of govt economic policies but who has recently been categorical about more economic reforms, states that ‘per capita income in dollar terms grew about 5% a year between 2012and 2025. Last year it fell, from about 2,750 to 2650 dollars and we slipped from being the 4th largest economy to 6th.’

So that in a nutshell is the issue we face. The economy is growing at 7% and more. There is however no trickledown effect because it is jobless growth. It has been like that for some time.

It is not a NDA or UPA thing. Productivity increase requires automation. That is why UPA gave us MNREGA to balance contradictions.

As demands for productivity and automation increased building to a crescendo we have got G RAM G and free ration for 80 crore.

So no one has the answers to fix this dilemma in the Indian economy so far.

Maybe that is because we have not opened the gates for free investment a la the Vietnamese model. We are a democracy; too many powerful lobbies would be disturbed.

So like the old cliché about India, authored by Joan Robinson, a British economist, ‘whatever you can say rightly about India, the opposite is also true’. The figures are right but they are also not right’…..

Standard

THE DELHI GOVT MAKES A MOVE

The last 8 years, Delhi continues to remain the most polluted capital of the world. As per a WHO report, its PM2.5 particulate matter concentration is 16.4 times the safe limit.

It was about 10 years ago that a state govt took a baby step to mitigate the situation when the Odd and Even rule was introduced in the capital in 2016 for vehicles to ply. Essentially a stop gap measure, it gave temporary relief rather than a permanent solution.

It is only in 2026 that the Delhi govt in a tie up with the World Bank has launched an 8,300 crore, Delhi Clean Air program. It is to run from September 2026 to August 2033.

After much too and fro, everyone involved has settled down on these major contributors to Delhi pollution. I say to and fro because for a long time stubble or parali burning in Haryana and Punjab was the biggest villain creating pollution in the city.

The major villain now is clearly transportation in Delhi. And that is where the state govt has made a move in its EV policy.

As of 2026, Delhi has 87.61 lakh vehicles registered, an increase of 8% over last year. 2 wheelers form the bulk, 59 lakh units. Cars and jeeps are at 21 lakh units.  An estimated 11 lakh vehicles enter and exit Delhi daily from the NCR area.

To put it in perspective, Delhi has more vehicles registered than Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai combined. Presently 3% of its total is EV.

Two wheelers contributions to vehicular emissions are 30%. Heavy commercial vehicles contribute 23% or so and private cars, taxis give out 20 to 25%.

If the PM2 figure includes dust kicked up due to vehicles, cars take up 34% of the share in comparison to lighter 2 wheelers whose share dips to 26%.

The state govt has taken the low hanging fruit in its latest EV policy. It has decreed that starting April 01 2028, new registrations for 2 wheelers in Delhi will only be for 100% electric vehicles.

 Additionally, starting 01 January 2027, new registrations for fossil fuel and CNG auto rickshaws and N1 goods carriers will only be electric. These are the Tata Ace/ Mahindra Jeeto category of small goods carriers for last mile conveyance of goods. These typically give a 100 or so kms per charge and can be charged at home.

For cars whose contribution to PM2.5 is alarming if the dust factor is included, the new policy only gives road tax and registration benefits for an EV purchase. For goods carriers also there is no push. If one buys an EV in exchange for an old BSIV car, there is a 100,000 direct incentive.

As things stand, it does appear to be business as usual. Improvements with such a policy promise to be incremental at best.

The range anxiety of car EVs has still not gone away. Most car owners are single car owners. Charging facility on highways is sketchy. Battery range at high speeds drops alarmingly.  Charging at home is available for 2 wheelers but not a given for cars as parking woes at home are common thus reducing charging at home options.

The EV policy promises 30,000 more charging stations till 2030. But roadside charging is not an inviting proposition. And that is the main reason why EV car penetration is limited for those doing less than 100 kms daily. This despite car makers offering Battery as a service (BaaS) to reduce upfront costs.

The concept separates the cost of the battery from the car price and the customer pays a rental fee per km or a monthly subscription. A battery costs 30 to 50% of the car price.

As a result of all these ifs and buts, EV car sales are not going above 8% of total car sales at present. As premier transport polluters, without addressing this issue, our emission story will be the same hand wringing affair.

If we are serious about reducing emissions by 2030 there seems little way out but to go the strong hybrid car route. In our stop go city driving conditions they will virtually be running on battery the whole time. The hybrid electric motor battery is smaller than in EVs and is charged on board while the car is running.

Emissions for hybrids are 25-30% less than ICE cars. If the same incentive of free road tax and registration is given to strong hybrids, it would bring our fuel bills down, reduce emissions and help tide over the issue in the interim, till battery breakthroughs and battery charging infra make EVs a go to option.

The fact is that the UP govt ran this free road tax and registration campaign for a year and sale of hybrids went up 4 fold. But then it relented maybe because the car EV lobby went bananas.

 It is what the customer seems to prefer in today’s EV environment. Policy needs to match customer requirement if it is to succeed.

One wonders why the govt is swimming against the current so resolutely and in the process, ensuring it is business as usual in meeting our emission goals.

Standard

AT EV CROSSROADS?

As per the Paris agreement on climate control, India has volunteered to strive for reducing emission of greenhouse gas intensity of its GDP by 45% below 2005 levels by 2030. Also to create an additional carbon sink of 2.5 to 3.5 billion tons of CO2 through increase of tree and forest cover.

The Indian transport sector emits roughly 300 to 370 million tons of CO2 annually. Emissions from transport have more than tripled since 1990. Private vehicle and freight growth also mean energy demands could double by 2050.

EV adoption and public transit improvements are primary policy levers targeting future reductions. The world is headed in that direction. 21 million EVs were sold worldwide in 2025, an increase of 20% over 2024. Additionally, 5 million Hybrid vehicles were sold in 2025.

In line with these aims the govt has set a target of achieving 30% EV penetration by 2030. In the FY 25-26, we had reached 8%. Monthly retail sales in mid 26 have however climbed to 11-12%. The growth is led primarily by 2 wheelers (58%) and 3 wheelers (35%).

The ethanol controversy thus becomes a sideshow in the goal of reduced carbon emission. There is comparison with Brazil and its successful ethanol adoption. A key factor missed out is comparison of land mass and population.

Our food needs far outweigh Brazil. Water needs for sugarcane and ethanol are already discussed in great detail. It is for bigger and better brains to decide if we can afford greater emphasis on ethanol, given that we are currently importing ethanol. Reduced mileage of cars that is now accepted by the govt will increase our consumption of petrol and ethanol, including fertilizer and water costs.

Be that as it may, what appears to be of greater worry is our not so impressive thrust in EV adoption to meet our emission goals? This after we have gone through 2 phases of FAME (Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles), EMPS and PM E-DRIVE.

  In his book EV Evolution, Sasi quotes the experience of a brave heart that drove from Bengaluru to Hyderabad, a distance of 565kms in an electric car. His points are illuminating.

‘We left Bengaluru at 2.30pm and reached Hyderabad at 0530 am the next day. Drive above 100kms/h and the battery drains fast. The highway has many charging stations but most are of 30 kw and few are 60kw- leading to longer charging time. Most do not have backup power supply. Each charging station has its own app which has to be downloaded for connection and payment. This being in remote locations, connectivity is an issue. On long distance drives, motion sickness is more for those seated behind as it is noiseless and the visual and auditory inputs don’t match the movement of the vehicle. If total discharge of the battery takes place, the steering is locked, car electronics is shut down and it has to be taken on a flat bed. It is definitely not family material.’

Clearly it is all still a work in progress.

Our EV push is being stymied by initially expensive cars, heavy reliance on battery and rare earth mineral imports and inadequate charging infra. We have a total of 30,000 charging stations approximately as of end 2025, approximating to one public charger per 235 vehicles comparing inadequately with China’s 7EVs/charger, US and Europe 14 and 17/ charger.

The other stumbling block is the near total Chinese domination of the EV battery market. Currently the space is dominated by Lithium ion batteries. China has two thirds of the world’s lithium and cobalt processing capacity. It also processes over 90% global graphite a key component for battery anodes. In total it controls over 80% of the final lithium ion battery cell manufacturing.

We did make an effort to woo Musk to set up shop here for Tesla. But even after tweaking policy to enable his entry into the Indian market, he backed out at the last moment. The govt was hoping that he would do for the Indian market what he did for the Chinese who ramped up their production quality thanks to Musk and have now overtaken him to be world leaders in EVs thanks to BYD and Li Auto, Nio and Xpeng.

Battery breakthroughs are continuously happening phenomena. BYD has come out with a fast charging Blade Li ion battery that moves from 10% to 70% in 5 minutes.

There is another option that the govt could make a move on. Toyota is currently producing hybrids in India and Maruti is badge engineering on the same technology.

Hybrids are a big solution to the infra constraints that EVs are riding on currently in India. It saves up to 50% fuel consumption. It has an on board charging system for its much smaller Nickel hydride battery, 1.7kwh. A comparable EV would have a 50 kwh lithium battery. In city driving the hybrid is running for more than 50% of the time given our driving conditions.

If we are serious about our goals of 2030, hybrids promotion seems to be a great stop gap arrangement till the non Chinese battery story for EVs is fixed. Toyota is almost there with solid state batteries.

It would our import bill; it would reduce emissions and reduce our dependence on the Chinese. And it would reduce our charging infra and battery range anxieties in one stroke.

The catch is the govt is not reducing taxes on hybrids the way it is on EVs. GST on EVs is 5%. On hybrids it is 40%. Maybe the EV lobby is ensuring this. UP had waived off road tax on hybrids making them about 3 plus lakhs cheaper and driving a 4 times sales surge of hybrids in that state alone. But that waiver has ended in 2025.

The fact is, if we do go this route, it would kill quite a few birds with one stone in the interim. If road tax exemption is added on, the push would be dramatic. Otherwise the 2030 goals seem too distant presently.

It is a call to take. Hopefully we will.

Standard

THE E20 SYNDROME

In the last six years the govt has faced two mass movements. The farmers from Punjab who were the protagonists the last time are incidentally back again. This time against the apprehension of what may happen to farming interests in the impending Indo US trade deal.

The govt has moved swiftly to assuage the fears of the farmers with a promise of talks.

The moot point however is why a govt, of a party that dominates the political landscape of the country so convincingly, faced two mass protest movements in the last six years. In both it ended up embarrassingly on the back foot.

The issue becomes even more vexed if one considers the near total support of various institutions the govt has at its disposal. In the institutional and constitutional space the govt has near unanimity at its disposal.

And yet social media is awash with cries of foreign hand and forces inimical to the development of India whenever a movement of dissent is launched.

The last time the foreign hand was raised with such intensity was when Indira Gandhi was the PM. Coincidentally that was the last time India had a strong leader at its helm who commanded similar control over the public space.

The E20 petrol ethanol blending exercise implemented by the govt maybe gives a clue. It was implemented without a formal announcement and quietly covered the country. No discussion on the issue was undertaken in the public domain.

There has been a huge hue and cry over the move of blending petrol with ethanol. Of course it has mostly been in the informal social media and only by default has the mainstream media been discussing it.

Initially Gadkari was the main govt votary of the exercise, defending it with great élan. It is only when the attacks on him became increasingly personal that Puri, the petroleum minister was handed over the baton.

The plot had become a little more complex with mainstream media carrying news that the govt was contemplating going beyond the 20% blending ratio to even higher levels.

In an interview to diminish such fears Puri reassured all and sundry that the govt would make such a move only after due deliberation. He went on to say that the govt would discuss the issue with stakeholders like the industry, car makers and petroleum companies before taking such a call.

He left out a crucial element in his listing. It could have been a Freudian slip but it did give a huge hint about what plagues a 12 year old govt. Missing from the stakeholders list was, you guessed it; the customer.

In all moves made by the govt the big element missing has been conversation with representatives of the most affected. Maybe because the represents the will of the people so convincingly, it does not need to have a broader based conversation with those going to be affected by its moves.

There is a pointer here. After the Rajiv Gandhi govt that was voted out, coincidentally on the back of a storm against the Bofors scandal, in the year 1989; there has been only one mass agitation. That was the Mandal agitation that was triggered by Rajiv Gandhi successor VP Singh when he launched the Mandal Commission report.

And the next one was the Ram Janmboomi agitation that was a religious agitation rather than one born out of discontent.

The bottom line is that after the 1992 turmoil on the RJ movement the next one was the farmers’ agitation in 2020. Clearly dissent in society was well managed by govts in this phase of relative peace notwithstanding the fact that we had some tremendous economic reforms. In fact poverty alleviation was a landmark achievement of this phase as was development.

What stands out as a big difference is that during this phase genuine coalitions governed the country.

By their very disparate and diverse nature, the parties ensured that only a minimum consensual agenda was implemented by the govt. Once implemented, all parties had little to crib about.

The point is bringing in uniformity in a country that is so diverse that cultural differences are marked every 300 kms or less is possibly a very tricky affair?

A case in point is the NTA that was the cause of the latest uproar. It is not that exam leaks were not taking place earlier. But since exams were being conducted state wise, the impact was localized. Centralizing the exam agency ensured the tremors were felt pan India.

Additionally it has increased the reach of the coaching industry in the country, making formal school education results almost redundant. That is a first in the world by any stretch. By different estimates the coaching industry is worth 1.5 lakh crores anymore annually.

The paper leak is just an example. The syndrome afflicting all powerful Central govts is best indicated by the E20 implementation. Maybe that is the approach that needs recalibration.

Has Gen Z ensured a rethink? Or will the relapse come sooner than later?

Time will tell….

Standard

BACK TO SQUARE ONE?

The US and Iran mess reminds one of the cliché about a middle age couple. They are all dressed up and nowhere to go.

The bottom line is that like a lot going on in international affairs today, the US and Iran is stuck with each other, with tons of compulsions. Like a middle aged couple, they can fight their daily battles but they cannot go all in and divorce.

Trump, for one is stuck between a rock and a hard place. I have said this before; he is juggling three mistresses at the same time; his ego, the midterm elections and Israel.

A salutary by product of this mess has been his dressing down of Israel, something Biden could just not do. Remember him wringing his hands in helplessness as the Israeli army massacred children in Gaza. In comparison the cooling down in Lebanon reads like a peacenik’s victory.

His survival instincts as a business man drove him to prioritize the midterm elections over all else. He is mortally afraid of a possible impeachment if the Democrats flip the two houses.

The MOU thus gave away more to Iran than could be explained away. No mention of the Iran missile program or support to its proxies in the region was one of the glaring ones.

Even the issue of the nuclear program that was the main bugbear did not clearly find mention in the MOU; about limiting the enriching of more uranium or handing over the 450 kg of enriched uranium. There were just some assurances on no nuclear weapons and handing over of the 450 kg in a mutually agreed mechanism.

Iran meanwhile got a lifting of sanctions, sold its oil and got some of its frozen money back plus a ceasefire in Lebanon.

The deal was tilted more one way and seemed to have been signed to keep the midterm mistress in play.

The bone of contention that has emerged is Clause 5 of the MOU. It gives Oman and Iran sole rights to administer, monitor and facilitate traffic in the Straits of Hormuz. But it also included the provision that no fees will be charged to commercial ships for 60 days.

The informed comment in the US was Trump had chickened out again (TACO). That hurt the second mistress, his ego. We in India know a thing or two about that.

There had to be a way to spike the MOU.

Some ships decided to avoid the Iranian marked routes through the Straits and sailed towards the Southern side of the Straits. The Iranians had made clear that ships were to sail closer to the Northern part of the Straits. Iran rose to the bait. They warned the ships. And then they attacked. But the Americans were in the area. How did the attacks succeed?

The Americans have justified their subsequent actions as they always do. Was it a planned move to recover ground given away in the MOU?

The playbook is set. It is back to the naval blockade. The Americans must feel that it has succeeded the first time and that it will bring the biggest bang for the buck.

The Iranian leadership appears to be in the hands of IRGC. Their capabilities may have been degraded but they appear to still have enough in reserve to trouble the region. The cease fire would have helped them recover. The blockade will hurt Asia and indirectly mount pressure on the US.

It was highly unlikely that there would be any takers for the US safe passage offer. Pressure will again build on the US as inflation at home increases and the midterm elections loom, if the operations linger. The Americans will most likely have factored that in.

What will be different then? Are the two going through the motions or is there a variation to the script? By keeping a window open for talks, it is clear that both sides do not want another round. But they are committed to not losing face.

Oh the ego mistress again.

If the safe passage offer is not taken up as is more likely, the US will have to make a move. It will most likely be an escalation of targets to blast. The Iranian response will center on hitting the Middle East countries more viciously in the hope to generate more pressure on them to broker a ceasefire. Are boots on the ground coming? The Israelis must be smiling.

The only sliver of hope in this mess is the fact that like the Pakistani army, the IRGC also runs a huge part of the Iranian economy. The 300 billion dollar bait is music to their ears. But ego matters.

It does appear that Trump has decided to go all in this time. The speed with which attacks have been resumed indicates that some new thinking has been factored in.

Buckle up guys there could be trouble ahead.

Standard

LUCK BY CHANCE?

It is the title of a 2009 movie from the Zora Akhtar and Farhan Akhtar stable. It highlights the devious nature of coincidences by which a guy gets his first break in Bollywood.

Rationalists will have us believe that words like luck, fate and destiny are but opium for the masses and what passes for all that we go through are mere coincidences. At the end of the day, it’s only hard work that counts.

But tell that to a sportsperson for example. They unlike most of us put in the sweat and tears every day into their field. The skill set is the same. One day they vault the moon. The other day they suffer a meltdown.

All that however is for the more erudite. Try to figure this one out.

It is an early Saturday morning. A golf tee off is planned at the break of dawn. I hit the course on time. The course is closed for the day. The day has started.

My partner in crime is the never say die kind of guy. Another course just 40 kms away beckons. We set course. Soon I am a speck in his rear view.

I have done a cross country on the car yesterday. The ride was smooth as butter. Suddenly a noise appears from the rear side of the car. My thumb rule says drive for a mile, if the sound persists, stop.

Turns out I have a humungous flat. A big sigh and I get to work. I inform my partner. He says no problem; join me as soon as you are done. I expected him to backtrack to help; so much for being partners.

It is a highway. Thanks to the roads being great these days, vehicles are zipping past at threatening speeds. The flat is on the right side of the vehicle. Needless to say I feel my backside exposed as I work.

The heavens intervene. A SUV, with the sunroof down and a kid reviewing the countryside like a military commander; appears. They stop and out pour four brats. Forget it; they look like angels to me.

Uncle is told to step aside as they replace the tyre in a jiffy. The spare is low on air pressure. I head home convinced that is the safer bet, given how the day is panning out.

My lucky day (sic), I run into the friendly neighborhood puncture repair guy. I ask him where to get a new tyre from, since this one did not last my thumb rule mile. He tells me about a shop in the thick of a crowded bazaar not far from my place.

I trek down to the place at shop opening time. He asks me car make and model year. Deal done I start the trek back with a tubeless tyre. No public transport is in sight. With the sun beating down, the trek is becoming exciting. Did I make a mistake?

Lo and behold, a guy pulls up behind me. A friendly neighbor insists on giving me a drop home. My stars have really turned I think. Reaching home I pick up the car and take the tyre to the puncture repair shop for tyre build up. All sorted I am sure.

The repair guy tries building up the tyre. Sorry he says, you have bought the wrong tyre. You will have to change it. I look up to the heavens. Someone is definitely the other way again.

Back to the tyre shop, this time by car. Sorry he says that size is in the warehouse, please come back at 3. Someone has really turned His head away.

I pick up the tyre at 3. When I reach the tyre puncture shop, his wife says he has gone home. Wait. I am done. I curse my stars. I tell her I am leaving the car. When he completes the tyre fit, tell him to call. I will collect the car.

I start the trek home that is nearly 500 metres away. At that time of the day, it seems like miles. Lo and behold a friendly shopkeeper with a shop nearby is coming back from lunch. He drops me home. My stars turn again?

It is not only limited to the drop, he picks me up when the car is done. It is 5 in the afternoon and I am home, all done.

 But a question bugs, was it a lucky day? Rationalists can stop reading from here on.

To be fair when I look back it seemed as if someone up there had a puppet on a string. Sometimes He was pulling, sometimes letting go a bit.

It was as if the template was set. There was to be no golf, flat tyre and I was to be homebound for the day. I made it more eventful by my actions. Were my actions, part of my destiny or plain Karma playing out?

Frankly that is a bit of a quandary. When we look back at our life events and turning points, we find a lot of our decisions wonky in retrospect. They seemed logical when we took them. Was taking them part of our destiny? That is why we are where we are in life? Or was it just poor intelligence?

It is a difficult one to figure out. Only safe conclusion stop as soon as an unusual sound is heard in the car.

Standard